At first Telemachus thought Odysseus was an old beggar and then he thinks Odysseus is a god. The god Hermes appears to warn Odysseus of what has transpired and gives him an herb called moly to counteract Circe’s potions. The whole journey Odysseus is trying to get to his home in Ithaca. Although both Circe and Calypso from Homer s The Odyssey fulfill the archetypal theme of the witch who hinders the protagonist s return, they have several differences between them. When he resists and is liberated by Hermes under orders from Zeus, Calypso offers him immortality if … Circe vs. Calypso Circe and Calypso both keep Odysseus for a long period of time distracting him from returning home to Penelope. No because he wants to make sure she has been faithful. Will this impact my Yahoo Account or other Yahoo services? The Lotus Eaters just made you lazy and forgetful but the Sirens caused death. How do Calypso and Circe keep Odysseus from reaching home? When she invites Odysseus to sleep with her, her language suggests that she sees sex as a kind of potion, a “magic work” that involves mixing two ingredients. What positive and negative character traits does Odysseus? Calypso enchants Odysseus with her singing as … How do the Sirens lure travelers to their destruction? Circe (/ ˈ s ɜːr s iː /; Ancient Greek: Κίρκη, pronounced ) is an enchantress and a minor goddess in Greek mythology. Calypso is a woman who carries the "true appeal" of a woman, beauty. Our team works as fast as possible to make data available, but it can take up to 30 days to receive your content download. This shows Odysseus’ hope, finding, and enormous love for his place. Which of his qualities do you admire? Calypso, on the other hand, is an egocentric, dominating goddess who holds Odysseus captive for seven years in hopes of marrying him. When Odysseus and his men reach this island, the men are beguiled by the sorceress, who turns them into swine and shuts them in a pigsty. Why do you think Odysseus chooses not to reveal his identity to his wife? By way of the messenger Hermes, Zeus orders Calypso to free Odysseus. You need to have JavaScript enabled to use this page. Your content will be formatted in JSON (JavaScript Object Notation) and might be hard to look through at a glance. Before the meeting with the Cyclops what had Odysseus received from Maron at Ismarus? What planning does Odysseus do before battling the suitors? He should have killed them all because they deserved it. Circe, like Calypso, is an immortal goddess who seeks to prevent Odysseus from returning home. In Homer's Odyssey, Calypso attempts to keep the fabled Greek hero Odysseus on her island to make him her immortal husband. Positive - smart: devises a plan of escape; negative - naive, too trusting: expects Cyclops to treat him like a guest. He hides weapons and armor in one of his rooms and he hides his identity. How do you describe Odysseus character? No, these changes are specific to Yahoo Answers. 4)How do Calypso and Circe keep Odysseus from reaching home? Impressed by Odysseus and filled with new sympathy for his men, Circe invites the Greeks to stay with her. In which adventure in this section does Odysseus act most heroically? What problem does Odysseus have with his men? How do Calypso and Circe keep Odysseus from reaching home? Was Odysseus right not to tell his men about his decision to sail toward Scylla? Calypso helps Odysseus by first agreeing to set him free, and then by promising him a raft and provisions for his journey home. The best examples of the true nature of women occur when Odysseus encounters Circe and Calypso. Explain. According to Homer, Calypso kept Odysseus prisoner at Ogygia for seven years. Circe, like Calypso, is an immortal goddess who seeks to prevent Odysseus from returning home. English, 06.01.2020 21:31, mistiehaas Where does circe tell odysseus to go upon leaving her Circe, like Calypso, is an immortal goddess who seeks to prevent Odysseus from returning home. The crew passes by the dangers and reaches the island of Helios, the Sun. Which positive and negative character traits does Odysseus demonstrate in his adventures with the Cyclops? Please tell us why you didn't find this helpful. Circe is an expert in drugs and potions. In Homer's Odyssey, Calypso attempts to keep the fabled Greek hero Odysseus on her island to make him her immortal husband. Here a party of twenty-three men, led by Eurylochus, goes off to explore the island. Her offer to “breed deep trust” between her and Odysseus sounds like a promise, but it also carries a threat. It’s the common, timeless story of the power women hold over men when it comes to sex. With her, he will be able to keep his identity as a man and enjoy the different pleasures she can offer. The Nature of Women Portrayed by Circe and Calypso in The Odyssey In Homer's composition, The Odyssey, the roles women play are very significant. What does this episode suggest about the main problem Odysseus has with his men? Which act begins Odysseus' revenge on the suitors? Why or Why not? He was in a deep sleep - Odysseus believed the gods put him in the deep sleep. Circe was a goddess of Greek mythology. Describe Antinous' treatment of Odysseus. How do Odysseus and his crew ultimately escape from the Cyclops? Yahoo Answers has shut down as of May 4, 2021. 5) What happens to the men who eat the Lotus? Don't be greedy. request a download of your Yahoo Answers data. Why do you think Antinous treats Odysseus so badly? They enchant him: What are Odysseus’ feelings when he is with Calypso and Circe? No, they didn't deserve to die, they were only hungry. Is the mood after the test altogether happy? Braving Scylla and Charybdis and not telling his men which path he was taking. Odysseus wants to kill the suitors and she just feels uncomfortable. These two characters illustrate the thoughts and feelings of how women how a woman feels and how they think. There, Odysseus meets Hermes, who is in disguise. Even though some suitors have been crueler than others, why does Odysseus take equal revenge on all of them? As of May 4, 2021 you can no longer access the site, but you can still request a download of your Yahoo Answers data until June 30, 2021. Similar - war, some evilness; differences - creatures that don't exist in our world. They sing them into rapture and get them to come toward the island and their boat crashes on the rocks. Based on Tiresias' prediction, which heroic qualities will Odysseus need to rely upon as he continues his journey? What is your first impression of Odysseus? No, it was meant to symbolize Argus devotion to Odysseus. Most people think of Circe as a sorceress, a witch, or even a temptress. How can I share my comments/feedback about this change. Also like Calypso, Circe is described as “lustrous” and “the nymph with the lovely braids,” and is first seen weaving at her loom. To enable JavaScript, follow these. What were Odysseus’ feelings when he was with Calypso and Circe? Also like Calypso, Circe is described as “lustrous” and “the nymph with the lovely braids,” and is first seen weaving at her loom. Odysseus is overcome with tears of joy in seeing his son, but Telemachus is afraid because he thinks he is a god or the gods are trying to trick him. While Calypso lied about being ordered to let him go, Circe obliged the moment Odysseus told her he wanted to be off. She is either a daughter of the god Helios and the Oceanid nymph Perse or the goddess Hecate and Aeetes.Circe was renowned for her vast knowledge of potions and herbs. If he is able to keep his men with him if they do not eat Helios’ cattle, if so, they die and Odysseus will return home longer. By chaining him up c. By promising him immortality d. By telling him he can't Leave Circe. In Book 5, when Hermes comes to tell her that she must let Odysseus go, a direct order from Zeus, she begins to stand up for herself, but abruptly stops her point. The men plunder the land and, carried away by greed, stay until the reinforced ranks of the Cicones turn on them and attack. Odysseus stayed with Circe willingly, while he had no choice with Calypso. Why is Odysseus unable to keep his men from killing cattle? Calypso enchants Odysseus with her singing as she moves to and fro, weaving on her loom with a golden shuttle. I believe the reason these two places detained him for longer than any other place was because Odysseus, when in the presence of these beautiful goddesses, was weakened severely. No, the content download is optional. Odysseus’s affection and respect for Nausicaa seems to be purely polite and possibly only to suit his own means, or at the most … Odysseus shot an arrow into the throat of Antinous. Calypso is holding him with her by force; she has no companions to help him back to Ithaca, nor has she a ship to send him in. We decided to shift our resources away from Yahoo Answers to focus on products that better serve our members and deliver on Yahoo's promise of providing premium trusted content. They get him drunk, stab him in the eye, and when he is blind they hid behind the sheep and take the sheep to their ship. Because he looks down upon the poor and he is just mean. What do you think about the way Odysseus responds to the three men that long to stay with the Lotus Eaters? He then meets his mother in the Underworld. However, if you choose to download your content, you have to do so before June 30, 2021. How do you think the problem of the suitors should have been handled? She seems like the most tempting offer for Odysseus besides his wife, but he denies her offer. They think he is an old beggar and shot Antinous by accident. How does Argus react to Odysseus' return? Is it a coincidence that Argus dies just when Odysseus returns? To assist you with this transition we've compiled a list of questions that may come up during this process. She offers Odysseus eternal life, and an end to physical suffering. Deny himself, patience, and restraining shipmates - because he will pass herds of cattle and not be able to eat them. In contrast to battles with men, Cyclops, or animals, sexual battles with women are sometimes much more difficult to win. I downloaded my Yahoo Answers content, how do I view it? Circe has magic powers, which she uses to turn some of Odysseus… We have resources on viewing and managing your account data that can help you understand your data download. The suitors' parents are after him too. Protected by the herb, Odysseus is able to overpower Circe and force her to return his men to their proper forms. Circe and Calypso are two very prominent setbacks in Odysseus’ return to Ithaka. What happens to the men who eat the lotus? Your Yahoo Answers data download will return all user-generated content, including your questions, answers and images. What do you think about the way O responds to the 3 men who long to stay w/the lotus eaters? How do Odysseus and his companions expect to be treated by the Cyclops? Explain. What do you think of Odysseus' plan for escaping from Polyphemus? How do Calypso and Circe keep Odysseus from reaching home? Charybdis is an enormous whirlpool that threatens to swallow the entire ship. What are Odysseus' feelings when he is with Calypso and Circe? Why does Penelope feel the need to test Odysseus, even though he has abandoned his disguise? Calypso and Circe The islands of Circe and Calypso in Homer’s Odyssey are places where Odysseus’ most challenging problems occur. Do the members of the crew deserve the punishment they receive for killing the cattle? Who does Telemachus think Odysseus is when they first reunite? Her father was the sun god Helios and her mother was, depending on the source, either a naiad or the goddess of magic Hecate.. She is rarely described as a goddess though. She wants to move their bed and his response is that it is rooted to the ground so he can't move it. Women in this epic are undeniably powerful — without the aid of Athena, Nausicaa, Arete, or Ino, Odysseus would never have made it back to the shores of Ithaca. How do Calypso and Circe keep Odysseus from reaching home? But women are dangerous as well, threatening the hero’s journey home. What would have happened if Odysseus had told them everything? What significant role does Ithaca play in Odysseus' epic journey. Even then, Circe helps the Greeks with supplies and advice. Circe, like Calypso, is an immortal goddess who seeks to prevent Odysseus from returning home. His most distinguishing trait, however, is his sharp intellect. The three women in Odysseus’s story represent three very different types of relationships. Attributes used to describe both women … Is it wrong for Odysseus to deceive his wife? Yahoo Search can be used to find answers and info from the web. He longed to be home. Why or why not? Athena pleads with Zeus to give Odysseus good fortune, saying that “he lies away on an island suffering strong pains in the palace of the nymph Calypso, and she detains him by constraint, and he cannot make his way to his country, for he has not any ships by him, nor any … He is loyal and wants to get back to his home. What happens to the men who eat the Lotus? Calypso Takes A Stand by Lauren Ziment. He is heroic - hero of the Trojan War. How does the danger posed by the Sirens compare to that posed by the Lotus Eaters? Compare Odysseus' emotions with those of Telemachus at their reunion. The answer to this can be found in Book 10. How do you feel about the way Odysseus responds to the three men that wish to stay on the island of the lotus-eaters? They enchant him. Explain. After all, it was her raising and love that saved him from decease. Why? Our Yahoo COVID page provides info and resources about the Coronavirus pandemic. The Lotus-Eaters. No, he chose to flee rather than kill in earlier parts of the epic, Yes, because he was determined and never gave up. Indeed, Scylla seizes and eats six men. If you were Telemachus or Penelope, how would you react to the stranger's arrival? Do you think that Odysseus' revenge is justified? The tale of Odysseus reaching Calypso's island has many parallels with the story of Odysseus and Circe. How does Penelope feel about the suitors in her house? 31 Calypso Takes A Stand . What ways in the world of the Odyssey similar to today's world and in what ways is it different? You can request a download of your Yahoo Answers data before June 30, 2021. Where should I go when I have questions in the future? Although devastatingly charming as the two goddesses already are, Circe and Calypso differ in their reactions and treatment of Odysseus after knowing about his strong desire to go home. The positive qualities of Odysseus includes being brave, loyal, and […] Antinous threw a chair at Odysseus and refused to give him food. What happens to the men who eat the lotus? Yes. What does Odysseus tell Penelope about himself? According to Homer, Calypso kept Odysseus prisoner at Ogygia for seven years. He longed to be home. Odysseus does not tell them of the imminent death, as they would panic. Because all the suitors abuse the homes' hospitality. He cared about them and he was doing his job. Charybdis will take them all and the boat also; Scylla will kill only six men. They expect to be treated like honored strangers. What is Penelope's test, and how does Odysseus pass it? Odysseus must face and overcome Sirens, Scylla, Charybdis, Circe, and others. You won't be able to download other users' content, questions, or answers. They forget about home and don't want to leave. Explain. Odysseus has the defining character traits of a Homeric leader: strength, courage, nobility, a thirst for glory, and confidence in his authority. Elpenor (his crewmate that died), Tiresias (prophet), Anticlea (his mother, died in grief). Hermes does two specific things that allow Odysseus to survive the meeting with Circe. Thank you! Yahoo Answers was once a key part of Yahoo's products and services, but it has declined in popularity over the years as the needs of our members have changed. 2. What does Eurylochus say to persuade Odysseus' men to slaughter and eat the cattle of Helios, the sun god? She loves him and wanted to do him immortal with her so they could populate together for all infinity, but he still longs to return to his place. Why does his act catch the suitors by surprise? How do Calypso and Circe keep Odysseus from reaching home? Where is Odysseus’ home? Odysseus needs to be the leader and he needs to guide them. One of the first differences is simply the way that each witch detains Odysseus. What lessons can be learned from the defeat of Odysseus and his men on Ismarus. a. To test her faithfulness and he needs to get rid of the suitors. What does this episode suggest about the main problem that O has with his men? Circe has magic powers, which she uses to turn some of Odysseus’s men into pigs. Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. A goatskin full of wine, seven golden talents, and a solid silver mixing bowl. What does the Council of Maron reveal about ancient Greek attitudes about hospitality? Yes, because they would have panicked and stop rowing. Circe does seem to hold a certain place in Odysseus’ heart, because she is the one he stays with voluntarily and has to be persuaded to leave, but Odysseus leaves the others without a backward glance – ‘with a happy heart’ in fact, in the case of Calypso. How does planning help him defeat his opponents? Odysseus passes on Tiresias' and Circe’s counsel not to eat the oxen or even land on the island. The whole journey Odysseus is trying to get to his home in Ithaca. Why does Odysseus continue despite the grim prophecies? Odysseus’ ship and the men on his ship escape and land on the island of Aeaea, the home of the witch Circe. Then Circe gave Odysseus advice about his rough journey ahead. Scylla is a six-headed monster who, when ships pass, swallows one sailor for each head. No, Odysseus needs to regain all the belongings the suitors took from him. Odysseus and his crew finally escape, having lost six men per ship. Also like Calypso, Circe is described as “lustrous” and “the nymph with the lovely braids,” and is first seen weaving at her loom. Take what you need and leave. If you had been in their situation, do you think you would have eaten the cattle? Explain. They won't impact your Yahoo Account or any other Yahoo services. Why does Odysseus choose to sail toward Scylla rather than Charybdis? How might Odysseus' feelings about the suitors differ from Penelope's? Whom does Odysseus encounter in the Land of the Dead? What laws of behavior and attitude does Polyphemus violate in his treatment of the Greeks? When will I get my Yahoo Answers content? Are Odysseus' actions in dealing with the suitors consistent with his actions in earlier episodes of the epic? By enchanting him b. Which character trait does Odysseus demonstrate in the Land of the Dead that he did not demonstrate earlier? What difficulties does Tiresias predict for the journey to come? Calypso feels it is her right to maintain Odysseus. What are Scylla and Charybdis, and why do they pose dangers for travelers? Poseidon is after him; must pass cattle of the Sun and not eat them (and keep his crew from eating them); get home and have fight the suitors of his wife and then leave again and make a sacrifice to Poseidon to appease him. Send any comments or feedback you have regarding this decision to yahoo_answers_sunset@verizonmedia.com. In the Odyssey, I felt that Calypso was not given the space to speak that she rightfully deserved. What were O's feelings when he was with Calypso and Circe? -Tiresias in the Underworld: Tiresias explains to Odysseus his fate in two ways. Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts with us. Ithaca: What significant role does Ithaca play in Odysseus’ epic journey. She is not sure if he is not a god in disguise. I would be frightened if I did not know who it was. What are Odysseus' feelings when he is with Calypso and Circe? They forget about home and don't want to leave. If they don't eat the cattle they will die and starvation is the worst way to die. Your feedback has successfully been submitted.